|
|
The Bargain Nexus - Atlantic Monthly
|
List Price: $59.90
Our Price: $24.50
Your Save: $ 35.40 ( 59% )
Availability: Usually ships in 1 to 3 months
Manufacturer: Atlantic Monthly Group
|
Average Customer Rating:   
|
|
Binding: Magazine
First Issue Lead Time: 6-10
Format: Magazine Subscription
Issues Per Year: 10
Label: Atlantic Monthly Group
Magazine Type: Consumer magazine
Manufacturer: Atlantic Monthly Group
Number Of Issues: 10
Publisher: Atlantic Monthly Group
Studio: Atlantic Monthly Group
Subscription Length: 365
|
|
|
|
|
|
Spotlight customer reviews:
|
Customer Rating:
Summary: Best magazine printed today
Comment: I've been subscribing to The Atlantic for all but two of the last 16 years. And I look forward to it every single month. What I like best is that they print articles of any kind of topic-I know many people were disgusted with the Britney Spears article and cover, for example, but it was another instance of an article that was unexpected and fresh. The great thing is that, having done the "Britney cover," they will never do another cover like that again.
The Atlantic is worth the subscription price if only for the occasional articles by Caitlin Flanagan and P.J. O'Rourke. Sandra Tsing Loh is also amazing. I like James Fallows and Robert Kaplan, too.
The articles from non-regular authors are always new and interesting content I wouldn't find any other place. A funny but thought-provoking article about whether an MBA is a waste of time was great-also a recent, poignant article about a professor at a community college who despaired of teaching his part-time, adult students to write. The infamous article that advised women to marry someone who falls short of Prince Charming before they get old and lonely was pure genius. Where else would you find an article like that, written from a such a thoughtful (and personal) perspective? The Atlantic is not afraid to buck PC thought.
Some people call the editorial bent of The Atlantic "centrist." I think that is wrong. The problem with the word "centrist" (or "moderate," for that matter) is that it implies that a person is mainly interested in compromising between two extremes-that he or she values general accord more than truth or principles. The Atlantic authors are not "centrist." They are writers who don't say "I am conservative, so I think this" or "I am liberal, so I think that." They are writers who say, "I've thought about this and..." meaning they THINK before they decide. I consider myself a social conservative with a liberal economic bent-a "crunchy con"-and I find The Atlantic deeply refreshing. Lock-step conservative writers just as infuriating as the mainstream media's liberal leanings. I don't find either of those things in The Atlantic.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Excellent Dentist Office Addition
Comment: I like the Atlantic, but I confess I do not like it enough so that I will continue to subscribe. I read it while awaiting treatment at my dentist's office, while on the train or at a coffee shop. In 45 minutes, I have had my fill. It is otherwise not compelling in its originality or capacity.
The articles are better than most popular magazines. I enjoy Mark Steyn and Mark Bowden, but get tired of Christopher Hitchens' proselytory writing tone.
Occasional issues have been dumbed down, are feel as if they are being geared for the Entertainment Tonight crowd.
The Atlantic is a good read in short spurts, but inconsistent over the entire issue, I now only buy a couple issues a year, at most.
Anthony Trendl
http://anthonytrendl.blogspot.com
Customer Rating:
Summary: Adrift and rudderless
Comment: I carried a subscription to The Atlantic for about a year and a half (most of 2007 and 1/2 of '08), until I just couldn't justify the expense anymore. I generally have five or so magazine subscriptions during any given year, and my criteria for renewing is whether or not I consistently read the issues from cover to cover or not. If I find that I'm slogging through the articles, uninspired by the content, then I bid it a hasty farewell.
Because I subscribe to so many magazines, I'm bombarded by offers through the mail for every periodical you can think of, some of which I wouldn't touch with a ten foot pole. When I first began considering a subscription to The Atlantic, the biggest stumbling block was the price. I think Amazon's price is lower than what I was ever offered, which was thirty-five dollars a year, but since I was aware of the reputation and longevity of the magazine, I decided to make the plunge.
I had no difficulties receiving my issues, which from reading the other reviews sounds like a problem with Amazon, and not The Atlantic, so kudos to their subscription department. When I recieved my first issue, the publisher also sent me a small information packet about the magazine, which I was very surprised to get. It explained how to read the address label on the magazine (something that was new information - to me, at any rate) to keep track of when the subscription ended, and where to find an account number. It also gave directions on how to end my subscription, should I ever find that necessary. Which I did.
One more note about how The Atlantic's subscription dept. works. Your subscription will be automatically renewed when the previous one runs out, and if you purchase the first sub. with a credit card, they'll simply bill you and you won't miss an issue. I understand why a business might want to operate this way, but as a consumer, I'm not a big fan of this practice. If I don't want the product anymore, I don't like the onus being on me to stop being billed for it. I'd much rather just let the whole relationship die a quiet, peaceful death.
That's the technical details, none of which affected my decision to end my subscription. That decision was based on the magazine's content and editorial direction.
Right away, I noticed I was having a difficult time finishing the magazine. At first, I accepted that the problem was probably me - I needed to get more comfortable with the magazine's format and recurring contributors. As I said, I subscribe to several different magazines during any given year, and usually there are one or two general interest, a literary journal, and some woodworking journals. The problem I had with The Atlantic was that each subject they covered - whether it concerned Torture in Iraq, Terrorists in the Phillipines, or The American Idea - each seemed to offer no new insights and which I frankly found to be boring. Their recurring features section, which included reviews of upcoming books, film, etc, seemed rushed and incomplete. I'd much rather read the full review on 1 book that intrigues me enough to buy or check it out than a sentence about 100 books that tell me nothing more than the bought and paid for blurb on the back cover. The magazine did approach each subject from a more centrist view than some of the other current event magazines (like Harper's liberal agenda, which I don't always agree with but I find infinitely more entertaining), but perhaps they needed a firm stance on something - it seemed as though everything went through a bland meter before publication to test out it's blah factor.
Additionally, I am an avid letter column reader. I like to hear responsible critiques and viewpoints to articles I've recently read. But I noticed a strange and what I thought was a cowardly trend in The Atlantic's letter pages: after almost every critical letter, the original auther responded, defending his article. Occasionally this can be interesting, but when it happens after almost every letter, I begin to think that if the authors have to explain this much, then they didn't do a very good job of it the first time around. Cumulatively, it had the effect of making the contributors sound defensive and whiny.
There are two issues in particular that eventually made me drop my subscription. The Atlantic began celebrating their 150th anniversary during my year and a half with them, which culminated in a double-sized 'American Idea' issue. It gathered an impressive number of thinkers and writers who were asked to submit a short essay on what they believed 'The American Idea' was. These essays ranged in size, but most were limited to a paragraph or two. I don't understand how anyone could think this exercise was worth the printing cost. I couldn't even get through it. Anything that may have been worthwhile would have been buried in the dross of gum flapping. And anything worthwhile would surely be worth more than two paragraphs.
The issue that finally put the nail on the coffin though was the Brittany Spears issue. I went to my mailbox and pulled out what looked like a People magazine, with a picture of Ms. Spears in dark glasses and obviously wanting to be left alone except some idiot was jumping in front of her flashing a camera. I was embarrassed that my postman had to deliver it. To be fair, I read the article, which concerned itself about the paparazzi that follow Ms. Spears around and generally make her life hell. Too bad for her. Since I consider paparazzi and entertainment magazines to be one of the rotting boils on the backside of this 'American Idea', I called up The Atantic's subscription department (with the handy number that came with the info package at the beginning) and cancelled.
If you like Ms. Spears, then there are plenty of outlets to get your fill of her. Personnally, I'd like to know how to purge my mind of this incessent celebrity culture injected into society's stream of consciousness anyway, but until they find a way to do that, I certainly don't want to be reminded of it any more than I have to. Especially from a magazine that ought to be focused on events more important than the plight of paparazzi. Poor little fellers.
Truth be told, I was expecting the hardsell when I called to cancel the subscription, but the operator was very succinct, and asked no questions and did not try to dissuade me. I don't know if she was getting used to those calls by then or not. Probably not. The bar for current events and important news items in this country is lowered every day - but in my version of the 'American Idea', there wouldn't be venerable institutions such as The Atlantic taking part.
Try this magazine one issue at a time. Perhaps someday it will find its direction again and steer by the light it has lit in the past. For now, though, I think it is adrift at sea, looking for something solid on which to ground itself.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Atlantic Mag forever!
Comment: My subscription has not started yet, but I'm eager to renew reading it. The Atlantic had been part of my life since I was a kid in the 30's.
Customer Rating:
Summary: Great magazine gone bad
Comment: I began subscribing to the Atlantic around the time of start of the war in Afghanistan, and was an ardent fan. I loved the reporting by James Fallows and Mark Bowden, Mark Steyn's obits, and Christopher Hitchens' erratic but occasionally terrific stuff. It was literary, combative, intelligent, centrist but never doctrinaire. But after a few years I noticed a worrying development. Stories kept cropping up that I suppose were meant to attract a young female readership. They were about boring subjects like healthcare and organic food. There was an editorial slant that was indistinguishable from the NYT or Slate. They ran a cover story about the shortage of good nannies and later an adulatory profile of Barack Obama. Steyn disappeared. The month I cancelled my subscription, Britney Spears was on the cover. I read later that the magazine was taken over by a new publisher around the time it went bad, and it had a callow young editor who was on a drive to raise circulation. Rather than screwing up the content of the magazine, they should have fixed their subscription department. At one stage I had four subscriptions going-- 3 of them gifts to friends, because I was such a fan. When I started a subscription or changed my address, it would take 5 or 6 months for the changes to be carried out. Even responding to my enquiries took weeks. -- A young female reader.
|
|
|
Editorial Reviews:
|
Covers the important issues of the day, from public policy and social trends to arts and humanities. Also contains sections on travel, food, and contemporary fiction and poetry.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
